Preston pulled off an upset over Everton U18 by beating them 7-6 on penalties in their FA Youth Cup fourth round tie on January 18, 2017. The game ended goalless and went to a shootout, where Ryan Harrington, Manasse Mampala and Michael Collins missed from the spot for EFC.
Penalty shootout Preston 7 Everton 6
Scored for Everton: Fraser Hornby, Liam Morris, Alex Denny, Morgan Feeney, Beni Baningime, Jack Kiersey
Missed for Everton: Ryan Harrington, Manasse Mampala, Michael Collins
Scored for PNE: Callum Roberts, Jack Burgoyne, Oscar O’Neil, Melle Meulensteen, Joshua Earl, Harry Garstang, Michael Howard
Missed for PNE: Alex Wood, Tom Stead